Pros: Good teamplay and novel cap point idea Cons: A little too dark Improvements: Easily fixed with brighter lighting Notes: Good work!

All-in-all its a good concept but the star-ship theme is kind of lost in all the cluttered bits. the underside was great with the pipes under the glass and the bridge is also neat. Love the iris doors (might need to re-texture the sides or add some lip so they aren't as obviously stuck in the walls) also might want to disable shadows on some of the hanging lights in the offices (splotch shadows aren't that fun to look at) umm the clutter... wow... i mean I guess thats what you're going for so I can't really say it's bad... it's just hard to see where my enemies might be coming from as my eye is looking all over the place trying to discern what it is I'm actually looking at. Now the textures are alright but it doesn't look like a TF2 map it looks like an HL2 DM or CS map using those high-def ones. Game play wise I also see some obtrusive issues with players getting "caught" on some door bits (only for a brief moment) and people being forced through small portals is kind of annoying. But all of those issues can be fine-tuned with a little work. Custom textures would be a very good idea here, you could easily make some simple looking bridge-like textures and other star-ship themed ones. also the handlebars on the stairs seem a little choppy and might need some connector bits or something to hide their intersections.

Whew. Aside from those nit-pickety details it's a good map worthy of a few runs (though the lighting is uhhh in need of some ambiance like maybe a value of 6000 or something higher)

Bananite

Pros: It's a good map, fun to play Cons: Needs better lighting/texture work. IE: More Polish

Looks good enough, except the textures. It has a CS feel to it instead of a TF2 feel. I think some maps that use CS textures would be immensely better if they tried fitting into the TF2 look a little more, and this map is a good example of it. If you're just looking for a decent looking map with good gameplay, this fits the bill.

Pros: Great design, flow, balance and idea. It works well. Cons: Textures, entity randomness xD Improvements: I think just aesthetic improvements are needed. Notes: For a really authentic spacey feel, I think some custom textures are required. It tends to be difficult with the default textures.

Everything looks perfect except for the brightness of certain areas (screenshot 1 and 5).