Posted by Blacktm
Posted by red caste
Animation: I don't really like the animations (No, i dont like the standard once)
Model: Bad, for the texture, or else its a nice model, by ValvE (that you forgot to credit)
Realism: I don't think that there is any realism over this, but the texture is okay.. i gues
Sound: Haven't tryed it, and i won't try because i don't really like it, theres no new model, there is still strings, the eye dosent fit right.. and.. there is alot
Texture: The Texture is cool, but it dosen't fit the ball, you have to scale it a bit down, or else its square []!
Note: Sorry mate, i just think that you have googled an eye, and placed it in, i like the eye texture, but make your own model, its not hard, its just makeing a ball, and then make some bumpmaps, but im doing a projekt myself with a moveing eye, so.. yea, sorry. Hope you will do it better next time! And i don't hate you, i just give you critism
Very poor criticism at that. I get the feeling you haven't even tried this submission, and you're giving it a bad score because you feel threatened that it may outdo your submission with a similar idea.
Duh, i have tryed it, but just because i don't like it, then don't come and say, that its very poor critism. And no worries, no eyeball from me, but i hate to do low rating, because i don't like low rating myself, but Sorry, i was just trying to tell him what to improve..