No offense, but your logic is rather backwards. If it looks good in game, does it really matter what it looks like in the VTF? You're just giving extremely poor reasons to mark it down. Since the whole point of using a skin, is to change the look in game, not to look at a VTF. Granted this skin could be better, but to say this only deserves a 7.7, simply because of something so trivial, is rather irritating to see.

Plus "Make it proper." really isn't C&C. (Constructive Criticism.) Please at least give him something to work with, something to change and something to improve upon. Nothing is more disheartening, than receiving an average or low mark, and not being told exactly why you received such a rating.

Pros: the texture in game looks oke but the vtf is realy messed up ( yes some poeple look to the vtf to ) Improvements: Try Next To To Pre Map Your Vtf File als could use a costum bump

Boba Fett 2D/3D Artist